December Community Mix-Along: Eggnog Extravaganza

December is a hectic month for a house full of musicians. I think I’ve had one single day so far that hasn’t included a rehearsal, gig, or performance of some kind. Mixing endeavors have been limited, but I did get this one together, and I think it’s worth sharing.

Mouthfeel for days. Flavor is a soft, slightly under baked cinnamon roll that’s been soaking in eggnog. Typical custard, cream, and spice players here. But LA Butter Rum and OOO Cinnamon Roll are both pretty unmistakable flavors and give it a unique twist.
I went conservative with LMP, not wanting to curdle the cream so to speak, but I think it might benefit from just a touch more.
Enjoy
And please, do not enter me in the spin.

15 Likes

Hi D.Sims, I am a Flavorah only mixer so when you get your Flavorah based recipe finished I sure would like to see and try it. Thank you sir.

11 Likes

Withhold from the drawing

16 Likes

Well I couldn’t finish out the year without another try at my white whale, vanilla eggnog!

13 Likes

Hey @robrrt1 I don’t see many mixers using Moose Milk, I really like it. It was a favorite of Zippy’s, I remember.

9 Likes

Moose Milk is pretty.good…Ty for the reminder

8 Likes

I searched that and found eggnog fudge! Actually, the search said exactly what you said and that it’s not available anymore or maybe rebranded. They recommended a similar product called Pennsylvania Dutch Strawberries and Cream. And there are some recipes shown that replicate the original. I can’t copy the search page but I searched, Old Ship Strawberries and Cream Eggnog.

6 Likes

Oh yeah, used in moderation (for me anyway), it has really filled out some my other experiments :grin:

9 Likes

I wanted to make a Eggnog concoction without using said flavoring. I ended up using more flavors than I wanted and I’m sure the TFA Cheesecake scares some but I’ll let others decide.

13 Likes

did you know there are 10 flavours of baileys liquer? what would happen if you mixed them all together?

12 Likes

Welcome to ELR Forum NIL8
Thanks for playing along, we appreciate it!

7 Likes

Cool recipe name :joy:

8 Likes

Nil8 happy new year…Were you talking about me here ??? Lol

8 Likes

I couldn’t let the year ring out without joining in despite everything going on. I took up Rocky with his alternate brownie idea but had zero brownie flavors so I used the Red Velvet Cake to push it towards brownie territory. The Dessert Chocolate has a cakeyness to it.

HAPPY NEW YEAR Everybody! :tada:

(I forgot…don’t enter me in the drawing)

13 Likes

Ha! I love that you did that. Brazilian Coffee is one of my favorites and a go to in many of my coffee mixes.

7 Likes

Happy New Year!
Naa I wasn’t but duly noted. I constantly heard many hated this flavor over the years but imo this is due to using it too high. One of my most popular flavors many moons ago had .25% in it so I know first hand it can be appreciated with good execution.

8 Likes

Yohoho Rocky, HNY!! Yeah thank you, for whatever reason never took to the forum. I apologize for never posting. After some digging, join date was indeed 2016 lol

8 Likes

Okay folks that was a fun month to end out 2025! Now for our Dec winners, chosen at random:


Congratulations :tada:

@Charlie6, I will contact you to get your info fir the gift certificate

@NIL8URBUDZ, contact Fiddy with your info if you don’t hear from him first

Thanks All who participated and followed along, we appreciate you :+1:

13 Likes

Congrats @Charlie6, and @NIL8URBUDZ.

11 Likes

Congratulations @Charlie6 and @NIL8URBUDZ :grin: :clap: :tada:

9 Likes