Hi everyone hope you’re good. I have this commercial juice and it’s the best dam peanut butter and jelly tasting juice ever!! Was wondering if anyone here has tasted it ? I’ve been on a kick to try and clone it or get close and everything I’ve tried just don’t do it. I’m sure it’s TFA peanut butter but the jelly part is the hard part. It’s the most wettest peanut butter taste I’ve ever tasted this juice isn’t dry at all and it’s sweet which I like. Let me know if there’s a recipe for it ? Thanks
how old is this juice? ie when was it manufactured?
& the jelly part, i assume you mean a usa type jelly (which would be jam to me)?
what flavour is the jelly/jam part?
I may not be able to directly help with a recipe but if you can describe in as much detail as possible every nuance you get it may help bring in more ideas from people with experience with certain flavours that bring said nuance to the mix?
But as an outright guess i would say you are probably right or at least on the right track in asuming its tfa’s peanut butter? or maybe their dx version? & possibly combined with another peanut butter? The jelly part im unsure, i only own 3 jam/jelly flavours & dont know of many others so it shouldnt be that hard to pinpoint/narrow down?
Sorry i couldnt be of more assistance but i have never tried this specific juice to have any real input. Hope you find something close though.
6 Likes
Rick that’s the name of the juice is Goat Herder. Here’s the description from Myvaporstore
The Goat Herder by Micro Brew Vapors
100ml Bottle
A delicious peanut butter and jelly flavored eliquid. The balance between the peanut butter and jelly is the right amount of savory and sweet.
65% VG / 35% PG
It doesn’t describe anything about if there is a bread note just that it’s a peanut butter and jelly. I agree we need a bit more info if they want any advice on attempting a remix. Is it a grape or strawberry jam. If strawberry then probably OOO Strawberry Jam. It could be any PB but most likely TPA.
6 Likes
Hey guys thanks for the reply it’s a strawberry jelly taste to me and it’s pretty simple but just the blend they did with it works wonders for me. I only have strawberry’s and blueberry flavour’s so my strawberry try didn’t work so I guess I’m need to get a jelly / jam flavor next to try. Thanks for the help… what’s a good jelly jam flavor ?
3 Likes
One of the best Strawberry Jams is OOO Strawberry Jam though it’ll probably need to be boosted with another strawberry (I don’t know how it is at higher %) if you want it to be present when paired with a heavy peanut butter. I have seen wonderful 2-3 ingredient commercial recipes that are full of flavor, but without having a sample of the e-liquid that you want to remix it hard to know how full it is or if it is only the two flavors. Peanut butter and strawberry jam. I’d grab a few different choices of peanut butter and a few different strawberry jams and experiment with those first. And if you feel like it needs some boosting or thickening just ask we have a lot of experience finding the perfect flavor combos to achieve your goal.
5 Likes
It could be flavorlabs strawberry jam , ooo strawberry jam or rf strawberry jam and toast. Most likely its one of those 3
5 Likes
I know that the description says that its just Peanut Butter and Jelly. I did a pretty good version of a PB&J sandwich with VTA Strawberry Jam and Cap Sweet Strawberry, even though VT Strawberry Jam wasn’t my favorite strawberry flavor it turned out good. Id probably switch to OOO Strawberry Jam @same %. And yes it is a secret that 2% of both Pudding Base and Golden Butter together create a untoasted buttered bread flavor. I had to dig deep to find this recipe.
PB&J Sandwich by McDuckie
Acetyl Pyrazine 5% (TPA) 0.25
Golden Butter (CAP) 2.00
Hazelnut (TPA) 0.75
Peanut Butter (TPA) 5.00
Pudding Base (VTA) 2.00
Strawberry Jam (VTA) 4.00
Sweet Strawberry (CAP) 3.00
Sweetener (Sucralose/Maltol) (TPA) 1.00
8 Likes
Psychic moment. I was just perusing juices and came across that exact one. I was tempted to try it. Being that I haven’t, I have nothing more to add to what’s been said but I agree with all of the above. It probably is TFA PB but SSA makes a bangin’ PB too. I can attest to OOO SB Jam, as well.
3 Likes
Hey @McDuckie I’m not sure I have TFA Hazelnut. Do you have a sub suggestion? Wouldn’t FW work here?
2 Likes
The TPA Hazelnut isn’t necessary it just makes the regular PB stand out better, you could just change to DX Peanut butter.
5 Likes
I learned that from the amazing Nachef. If you want to toast the bread I like to add any (Tpa, Cap, Fw) Toasted Almond @1% to the bread mixture.
6 Likes
True about the Pudding Base. Even all by itself it tastes like bread & butter.
I’m messing with it again right now for another Christmas Pudding recipe for myself.
5 Likes
are you not gonna share? Lol I Love 
Christmas Pudding. That and a Bread Pudding with cinnamon, raisins and a brandy cream topping. Never had much luck with either. Oh damn now I’ve got bread pudding on the brain.
3 Likes
LOL! Of course I will Mc 
I’m just trying to experiment with different types of flavors for the custard sauce. I liked the recipe I made for Christmas back in '22 for my first try. I know probably nobody has the Welsh Pudding (Chef’s), but I mainly made it for myself. So, I’m working on one now with more common custards. That Xmas Pudding (VTA) is sooo good with an easily recognizable brandy note in there. 
From 2022…
4 Likes
Well, well, well… looks like we’ve got a “Goatly” task on our hands here! While I can’t help you nail down the recipe for The Goat Herder, I do know a thing or two about herding goat-loads of flavor into a mix. 
Now, peanut butter and jelly, you say? Sounds like the “G.O.A.T” of combos! If it’s as wet as you’re saying, maybe they’ve got some secret sauce to keep it from being a dry pasture of flavors. Probably a bleat-load of jelly to balance out that sticky peanut butter.
TFA Peanut Butter is a good start, but nailing that jelly might be the herd mentality here. Could be something berry-goaty, or maybe even a sneaky grape escape. Don’t overlook a touch of marshmallow or something smooth for that wetness—every great herd needs its shepherd, after all.
In the meantime, I’ll be over here grazing through my recipes and pondering if I should start a juice called The Old Goat’s PB&J. 
Good luck, and may the goats be ever in your flavor!
6 Likes
