I agree with your overall sentiment here, but I can't help but poke a bit of fun at the following:
Bwaaahahahahaha "commercial quality"!! FOCL
C'mon bud! You and I both know how many truly "meh" eliquids are out there for retail sale (=commercially). The majority of them are "ok" at best, even after you filter out all the damned strawberry variants of the same 3 or 4 recipes.
I've only had one local vendor's liquid impressive enough for me to consider calling it "commercial quality". I've tried quite a few of Beard Co., and many more of SB's offerings too, including the crown or throne, etc lines (all of which seem to be hugely popular) and the majority of even those were merely ok. A few were even good.
I've only had one so far that just seriously dazzled me, and unfortunately, I don't have the option to give them due credit. But I can say that ELR is THE BEST single source for multiple seriously impressive talents. So without violating a trust, I'll say that everyone here already has access to the best commercial liquids IMO!! Or at least variations thereof!
/to the general topic:
Anyways, I think if you try a recipe here, and it's within your palette range, then it's only right to rate it (comments preferred). As long as it's not rude or belittling, etc, then it should be worthy of posting your thoughts. It may inspire, educate, or enhance a mix for someone who feels they're close, but decide to reach out there, instead of on the forums! =)
JMHO and YMMV!