Butter Rum makes a Butterscotch mix taste almost exactly like RY4 not Toffee.
Huh, RY4 really ? Iām getting buttery rich velvety texture atop of my Butterscotch rich forward Toffee rich mix with a kettle corn and molasses finish.
1 Like
I think I used it too high along with too much Caramel now that I look at it a bit closer.
1 Like
Caramelā¦ now that makes more sense on the RY4 end of it. With Butter Rum LA less is more to me.
1 Like
I used a natural caramel cream with butter rum, tasted almost just like RY4 Double TFA.
1 Like
interestingā¦well you may of stumbled on to a gold mindā¦maybe I could add a tobacco to it !
Now this is not to say that it wasnāt good as I was enjoying vaping it last night driving my wife and boy around our housing development. One guy walking by said, āSomething smells delicious, are you making candy in your car to pass out for Halloween?ā So many people were asking what that smell was, it was my tester for @Pugs1970ā¦
3 Likes
LOL ! The Candy Man BB 
Well do I have to coerce the recipe out of ya ā¦care 2 share privately
that sounds perverted I swear I am not intending on being that way BB you know me better than that. hee hee
3 Likes
I get the feeling that even if we donāt nail down this particular liquid something glorious is going to come out of this threadā¦
3 Likes
Yea, let me finish this patients chart, looking up a code.
1 Like
Take your time
I quit reading about 1/3 of the way down so if Iām repeating anything forgive me.
These are ideas only - no recipe experience to back them up! Things to possibly tryā¦
Acetyl Pyrazine - 2-3 drops per 10ml (help with popcorn)
Salted Caramel
Butterscotch (MF) probably mentioned, and if you donāt have it I donāt suggest buying just to try for this recipe
Liquid Amber (FA) starting very low
Most likely the liquid maker uses high percentages of sweeteners. How do you coils fare using this recipe compared to your own mixes? If they gunk up quicker (worthwhile test) you can bet they use high sweetener content which tends to make mixes appear better to many, many people, myself included.
All this said, I donāt own any popcorn flavors so ignore me if these ideas seem wack.
2 Likes
Iād never ignore your advice Robert, liquid amber is interesting, and I have that, itās a bit less of the popcorn and more of the butterkist coating Iām after, Iāve got some bits coming either today or tomorrow to try out and Amy and BB have both come up with blinding ideas, so somewhere along the way something great will get created lol
Thanks for the input dude š
3 Likes
The only thing here that Iād like to bring up is that the e-liquid maker is in Malaysia, what kind of flavor concentrates do we think they would use there? Would they import TFA, FA, INA, FW or anything we use? They have all kinds of flavor concentrate sources locally to them there in Malaysia, what are yaālls thoughts?
Hangsen is made somewhere in Asia you think theyād use them.
2 Likes
Iām guessing that they use cheap super concentrates.
2 Likes
Youāre welcome Pugsly! The Liquid Amber was an idea to help with that faint sour note often found in many butterscotch flavors. Having never tried the juice you like Iām just setting off a Claymore Mine trying to hit something 
2 Likes
@Pugs1970, this is what Iām going to try when I get the Natural Butterscotch and the Salty Butter Balls in. I wonāt have them till around Thu. or Fri. but here is my 3rd tester;
Threw in that Liquid Amber idea from @SthrnMixer, thanks Robert, youāre one of the best information sources on here. Did I ever tell you I really like you a lot for that?
3 Likes
Aww man, what a nice compliment! Thanksā¦although I donāt feel I live up to such an honorable mention.
1 Like
you really do man 
1 Like