I’m kind of having an issue finding a toffee that actually tastes like a toffee… here’s what I’ve tried so far
Health Cabin Toffee and TPA’s English Toffee
1 Like
I too am having trouble. It’s an interesting flavor that relies a lot on texture to really pass as authentic. FW has a Toffee flavor that I’ve had a little more success with but I’m still fiddling. Caramels and Butterscotches are needed to really set this flavor off I feel.
4 Likes
I’m looking for a good Toffee, too! I’ve tried FW Toffee Dream Cream, but it’s def. too nutty IMO. Not bad though, but too nutty - even on mesh.
2 Likes
OOO has a toffee butter I’m wondering if ya mixed it with TDC FW if it would make it more realistic both are good as mixers but not as the main profile. I also have LA’s Natural toffee it too is so so thou compared to those.
2 Likes
TFA butterscotch and TFA caramel original tastes like english type toffee to me. I made a werther’s mint type mix using them. I really like butterscotch so used a lot, but as a toffee base I would try 6/1 butterscotch/caramel. For example 3% butterscotch, 0.5% caramel.
5 Likes
Yesterday I ordered German Flavors Toffee from Vapers Tek after looking at reviews of several different brands of toffee. I saw comments like “Very buttery and creamy tasting, a true toffee flavor. Rich… sweet… a lot of ‘body’.” [edit: these be the words of Pro_Vapes]
So I ordered it. It should arrive by next Saturday and find its way into a mix by Sunday, and a week later my wife (the toffee judge) will deliver her verdict!
2 Likes
I’ve gotten it to taste bakery like in a cookie base but no, never have been able to get that one right.
2 Likes
I got that review from the Vaperstek website. I don’t think I ever got around to using it tho. I just got Amoretti’s English Toffee and the finger taste was very good. I mixed a standalone yesterday. I’ll do a standalone of GF Toffee to test the two side-by-side. I’ll report back in a week or two.
4 Likes
I like the toffee butter too. I’m not so keen on the English toffee
2 Likes
I wonder if that would work for FA’s Caramel and butterscotch hmmmmm
2 Likes
I’ll be doing similar next time. I have FA butterscotch and TFA Caramel original. I did it last time with 7% TFA butterscotch and 1% caramel, in a mint toffee mixture. It turned out pretty nice, TFA caramel is fairly strong. Not sure how FA’s caramel compares? They’re butterscotch might be a bit stronger so I’d probably go 5/1
2 Likes
What is your favorite butterscotch? I love that flavor but I struggle with getting it to work without overpowering everything else in the mix.
1 Like
Only tried the 2 so far, I like TFA’s, not tested FA’s enough yet, will be using it later today though as it happens 
I found TFA’s pretty nice, if a little on the weak side. Found I needed to use 5%+ to really get what I wanted, but then I really like that buttery toffee butterscotch taste to begin with. Planning on trying a few others along the way.
1 Like
Let me know how it goes with FA for sure. I tried what I believe was Delosi when I started mixing and that wasn’t good. I would love to get a nice butterscotch to work well!
1 Like
I love FA’s Butterscotch BUT I add sweetener to all of my mixes so I think that helps LOL
1 Like
That’s a vote for FA for sure, I use a lot of marshmallow for sweetener… I’m too fussy maybe
1 Like
Toffee flavour to me very rich buttery sugar goodness! Lol
A lot of the flavour profile, for me, is the waxy almost greasy mouthfeel?
1 Like
Depends, there’s many different types of toffee, but the better stuff should be rich, buttery, caramel tasting. At least the better Irish & UK toffees are. A touch of brown sugar in there sometimes too.
2 Likes
As a Brit I may be biased but we do have the most luxurious creamy toffee! Lol
4 Likes
I actually believe that, my father was 1/2 Welsh and 1/2 Irish he loved good toffee.
3 Likes