I’m going to nominate North Philly for the list.
3 Likes
Do you remember Beard Vapes The One Strawberry? Fifty bar renamed it SB donut cereal milk and wow, it’s as good as i remember it. I remember polishing off my last bottle thinking I’d never be able to get another bottle.:that one is in my car disposable stash for good. I was thinking Rainbow Road custard but that was was Jam Momster I think…I want nothing to do with cooling though, so I’ll skip that one.
5 Likes
My all time favorite. For years I only vaped that. I saw that Fifty Bar brought out the disposable one.
I haven’t tried it…thought it might not measure up to the original. But, thanks to you mentioning
it, I’m getting a bunch…especially for in the car! Thanks 
5 Likes
Well I know of it. I can honestly say that I have never tried it. I may have to try it.
3 Likes
It definitely holds up, I was pleasantly surprised!
6 Likes
Pulled this out of my “never tried” section and boy I’m glad I did. Been there for over a year and finally getting to it. Loving it!!!
8 Likes
A little too sweet for me but the recipe is good
4 Likes
Sometimes those old school recipes are just awesome. I was never wowed by Rose milk, I was more of a MOD MILK Strawberry Milky Goodness fan. I actually have the urge to mix up some good old school MR Good Vape MOON SUGAR.
5 Likes
Found the recipe, will give it a try if I have the flavs (the mr. Good Vape moon sugar one) thanks Duck!
Edit: Darn I don’t have the Caramel (Original). I have the Caramel (Original) (DX) (TPA) is that the right one under a different name?
5 Likes
My attempt at DIYFS Metro Man. Strawberry and cream with notes of donut, hints of lemon cereal and a caramel glaze. Not bad, but a work in progress…Leave the walnut out, it’s just there to check the all the boxes for TMA 
WIP:warning:
And I have @lukeloop ’s Wadey Rings ice cream in an Osiris mini , I’ve mixed close to 1000 mls of this- it’s delightful 
https://alltheflavors.com/recipe/171288-wadey_rings_ice_cream
6 Likes
Wow @Lynda_Marie, I have ZERO walnuts in my collection, but that’s a good looking mix. Also, somehow I completely missed Luke’s Wadey Rings. Thanks for that.
2 Likes
I have WF and FA…WF is just a creamy, buttery accent with little to no walnut flavor…FA is dry…a little more nut flavor, but being so dry…I never use it.
It was a fun one to mix, thank you! It’s better than DIYFS’s version imo 
It’s a WIP for sure but I’m confident enough with it to post… final might just have zero walnut, who knows lol
So so SO good! No lemon pledge, just loopy creamy goodness! Luke’s got a bunch of amazing loop recipes on ATF, I’m planning a mixing day to mix a couple of his other loop mixes.
3 Likes
Yes the Caramel OG (DX,) is fine. I’ve used it before and it works good. Though the original recipe created by Gary Riddle consists of 8% Cap Graham Cracker, 4% Cap Sugar Cookie, 3% Cap Caramel, and 1% Cap Super Sweet. I also typically mix it up with TPA GCC, Cap Sugar Cookie and TPA Caramel OG, and Ethyl Maltol.
4 Likes
Mod Milk Strawberry Milky Goodness
Butter Cream - Capella 1.50 %
Graham Cracker - Capella 0.50 %
New York Cheesecake - Capella 0.75 %
Ripe Strawberries - Capella 4.00 %
Super Sweet - Capella 0.25 %
Sweet Cream - Capella 1.50 %
Sweet Strawberry - Capella 6.00 %
Vanilla Bean Ice Cream - Capella 1.25 %
Vanilla Custard - Capella 3.00 %
6 Likes
That is almost identical to the Cuttwood Unicorn Milk release back in the day…Ill bet the SB combo in the ine above makes it better…I vaped gallons of this one
6 Likes
It probably is the same recipe. I found mine on Pinterest. I changed the percentage of Sweet Strawberry and added Ripe Strawberries because I felt like the strawberry wasn’t upfront enough with just Sweet Stewwberry.
6 Likes
Not a finished recipe yet but I enjoyed this mix,
Blueberry and pomegranate with a little creaminess and a touch of vanilla.
Inspired by the description of Bad Drip’s Bad Blood commercial liquid. (I’ve never tried the original)
I still have a few variations in mind to try so not going public yet.
It was at about five weeks before I tested it and had plenty of flavor and good body/fullness.
5 Likes
Thank you for the info, McDuckie!
I still haven’t picked up Cap Caramel although it’s been on one of my BCF wish lists forever.
I mght have drifted a bit too far from the original in a tester I just mixed - I replaced the Cap Caramel with a combination of FA Caramel/FLV Caramel/LA Butter Rum.
I’ve never had the original MGV Moon Sugar so if turns out alright I guess I won’t know the difference!
3 Likes
I was going through some old recipes of mine to find something interesting to mix and found this. I completely forgot that I had created this. back in 2020. Its so simple but really tasty especially if you like coffee vapes. I just mixed this up again last night and its already really good. It has a surprising clear separation of the main whipped coffee which hits first, and the FA Milk comes in on the exhale.
6 Likes